Monday, June 6th, 2005

I Summon You

My favourite part of Spoon’s new Gimme Fiction is in the outro of “Sister Jack”. In what has been a pretty straight 4/4 stomping rocker, they suddenly add an extra beat in the descending riff – the first time I heard it, I did a double take because I thought my CD was skipping or something. No, it was just one of the brilliant little touches that Spoon throws into their song arrangements that make their records such a joy. I’ve only experienced their live show once before, way back in September of 2002, and to be honest, I don’t remember much. Just that from my vantage point in the Horseshoe, I couldn’t see anyone in the band except Britt Daniel – for he is so very tall and his bandmates are so very not. It’s kinda funny to see. But yeah, back then I was still very new to Spoon so last night’s sold-out show at the Opera House was the first time I’d seen them as a fan and with a full knowledge of their catalog.

Opening things up was The Clientele, from London, England. They had been recommended to me in the past as the sort of thing I might like, yet none of the handful of tracks I sampled ever seemed to make any sort of impression. Still, I was willing to give them a shot to impress in a live setting. Being right up front, however, I was actually located behind the PA stacks and given that they are quite a quiet band and Alasdair MacLean’s Vox AC30 was pointed directly at me, I didn’t really hear much of anything but guitar. It was pretty guitar, sure – MacLean has an interesting spidery sort of fingerpicking style that I rather liked – but over the course of the set it was all very same-y. This certainly wasn’t helped by the fact that he left his tremolo pedal on for the duration, making it seem like they played one song for 40 minutes (or 10 four-minute songs that all sounded the same, I couldn’t tell). So yeah, a bit of a pity, that. And it wasn’t just where I was – reports from the balcony were that it all sounded the same up there as well. I won’t discount checking out one of their albums in the future, but they didn’t make a sale last night.

Curious thing about the headliners – for the first half of Spoon’s set, they were good but seemed to be holding something back. They were like a prizefighter circling the ring, sizing up the opposition but not thowing a punch. They obviously had the potential to do some serious rock’n’roll damage, like a coiled-up spring waiting to go off, but either by design or not, it apparently wasn’t go time. Then at exactly the halfway point of the set, they let loose a feedback-drenched “Paper Tiger” followed by a revved up “Small Stakes” and then it was on. From then on, they were tight, sinewy and grooving with just enough of a ragged edge to keep it dangerous – sometimes I forget just how unique Spoon’s sound is. There was no real knockout moment where they reached transcendence, but they came close with the extended jam-out on set closer “My Mathematical Mind”. While they may not have left the audience out cold on the mat, but they landed enough blows to get the decision. And in case you couldn’t tell, I know shit about boxing. But I’m sticking with the analogy anyway.

For my money, Spoon will always be a superb studio band first and foremost, but they’re no slouches onstage, either. I wonder how much of a difference it would make if the rest of the band were able to offer up some more stage presence rather than leaving it all to Britt Daniel and his dancing feet. Obviously he’s the focal point (did I mention how tall he is?) but that’s not to say he couldn’t use some support every now and again. But these are minor points – after almost two years away wherein they’ve dropped the “next” from their “next big thing” status, it was good to have them back in Toronto with a fine show. Photos tomorrow, I am ninety kinds of tired as is – staying up to play photomat was simply not on. But I was right up front so I got some decent shots of one sweaty Britt Daniel. Whoo! Update: Photos up!

Largehearted links – A brief look at the history of My Morning Jacket, courtesy of Flagpole and Stephen Malkmus talks to about his new album Face The Truth and fatherhood.

Feist tells The New York Times (Bugmenot) what music has been keeping her company lately. Via Pop (All Love).

np – Catherine Wheel / Ferment

By : Frank Yang at 8:34 am
Category: Uncategorized
Responses are currently closed, but you can trackback from your own site.
RSS Feed for this postNo Responses.
  1. vsmith says:

    What? No word on six by seven splitting up?

  2. Frank says:

    Aw, man…

    Hadn’t been by the website lately. Not surprised, but disappointing.

  3. David says:

    Would you, thus, recommend that if one was faced with either seeing Spoon/Clientele vs. StephenMalkmus he should opt with SM?

  4. Frank says:

    I dunno, I’ve never seen Malkmus live. I do like Spoon’s material better than SM, though, so personally I’d opt to see Spoon. But that’s me.

  5. Neil says:

    First time I saw them. I like their albums quite a bit, but I felt strangely detached from the show last night. I had been expecting to get my ass rocked five ways from Sunday, but the show seemed somewhat underwhelming. They seemed… tired?

    That said, it was still a good show overall. Great to see a sold-out crowd.

  6. skizz-o says:

    I hear ya, Neil. Spoon’s not that great live. Good, not great.

  7. Chris says:

    Same situation and reaction as Neil…Really wanted to love this show, but only thought it was decent, and left before the end as I beat – didn’t help when the opener subscribe to many of the ills of "indie" the brand. some charisam

  8. Thierry says:

    I didn’t make the Spoon show (I’ve always had a love/hate relationship with Spoon – LOVE the melodies and arrangements, hate some of Britt’s more Gavin-Rossdalesque vocal inflections), but I thought I’d mention that Pony Da Look and the Hidden Cameras were fantastic at the Phoenix last night, and the Joel Gibb and his 18 bandmates managed something I’ve rarely seen in Toronto, city of the sullen hipsterati: they got a part of the audience to actually dance at a show!

  9. James says:

    Thanks for your always dead-on assessments. I’m a Spoon fan from way back (was at their first Toronto show in 1998!). I think you’re mistaken about their last time here, though. It was actually September of 2002 at the Horseshoe. See my setlist and ticket stub here: http://…/

    I think the first half of the show Britt was having some trouble singing in that high register that so much of GF is sung in. They finished well, though. Not the greatest Spoon show I’ve seen, but I always love seeing them live. Looking forward to seeing your pics.

  10. Frank says:

    James, you are correct – I misread my past concert list. it’s been 2.5 years since Spoon has been in T.O.

    Oh, and the photos are up now.

  11. claire says:

    "good, not great"? to me, they’ve been one of the most consistently satifsying live bands i’ve seen. but maybe that’s because i’m a girl and mr. daniels = hottie mchott. i gotta say the main post confirmed what i figured about the clientele. i love some of their songs (although not always a fan of the overly breathy singing), but i’m not sure they’d come off well, opening for spoon, let alone spoon playing its largest venues ever. guess i’ll find out saturday.